Mally Starlight Eyeliner

Save For Later

If I’m going to wear eyeliner it has to be waterproof. Between sweat, allergies, and occassional tears my eyeliner is usually non-existent by the end of the day.

Mally Starlight Eyeliner is just the product I’ve been looking for. It comes in 15 shades and only costs $15. Considering I pay at least 10 for non-water proof pencils I think that’s a great deal.

Shade: Milk Chocolate

Shade: Deep Violet


What I loved

1. Great pigmentation: You get great color payoff in  one swipe, no need to go over and over to get a dark line
2. Smooth and silky: They just sweep across your eyes, there is no pulling or tugging
3. Great lasting power: They lasted all day!


What I didn’t like

1. It was very easy to get them on the top and bottom lash line. However, it was more difficult to get them on the waterline.

You can buy it at


Disclaimer: Baking Beauty received press samples of the above items. No compensation was received, and I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions are mine alone.