Maybelline One By One Review

Maybelline One By One Review

Maybelline says: Instant Clump-Free Volume

Claims: 3/5
Baking Beauty Says: The mascara does a great job of lengthening and separating my lashes. However, I didn’t see much volume, and it clumps if you try to use more than one coat.

Nevertheless I like the way it defines my lashes for an everyday look.

Pigmentation: 5/5 I accidentally picked up the Brownish Black shade. However, it still darkens my lashes quite a bit. I’m sure the blackest shade is even better!

Texture:5/5 This mascara makes my lashes feel almost as soft as Mega Plush. I dislike products that make my lashes crunchy so I appreciate this.

Lasting Power: 4/5 It lasted throughout most of the day. However, after a few hours they looked a bit deflated.

Packaging: 4/5 Cute packaging. I really liked that the brush was outside the mascara tube so you could see what it looked like in the store!

Have you tried this mascara?If not what’s your go-to for an everyday look?

Available at: Your local Drugstore and for ~8.00


Speak Your Mind


CommentLuv badge


  1. That makes me a little nervous that it clumps after one coat. I would still probably try it because everyone is different.

  2. I think i’ll give this a try. I have to buy new mascara today, so it’s worth a shot. I’ll buy blackest black!

  3. I am always struggling to find a cheap mascara that works! Thanks for the great review!

  4. I love Maybelline mascara, it works great for me and I can always find it on sale!

  5. I hate crunchy lashes too! It feels so unnatural!

  6. great review, love the rating system. I wish all mascaras had the wand on the outside for packaging so you could see it!

  7. I saw this in the store the other day and was wondering how well it worked! Thanks for the review and your honesty!

  8. OOOh thanks for the review!! I can never find a good mascara so I’ll have to check this one out. Mine are always clumpy :/

  9. Great review. I’m always looking for the perfect mascara. I haven’t found it yet but it’s good to know that this one works pretty well if you only use one coat. Now I’m off to read your Falsies review.

  10. I’m still searching for the elusive clump free mascara. I know its out there. I’ll be giving this a try until I can find it.

  11. I just keep buying mascara but can’t get it right :/ I wish I could master applying it 😀 like how expertly you do.

  12. I have tried it before and I wasn’t too impressed with it. Actually I was disappointed because they have the best of mascaras with their best-seller… I forget the name of it but know that it’s pink and green!

  13. I don’t know if it is the mascara or something you do, but I love how your eye lashes are individual instead of looking matted!

  14. I’m digging the definition of the lashes….will have to try this one!